A pediatric client substitutes interdentalized sounds for s and z and says /θɪnk/ for sink; phonemic contrasts are intact. What is the most likely diagnosis?

Prepare for the SG CSD Prequalifying Exam with our comprehensive quizzes! Study with multiple choice questions and detailed explanations. Boost your exam readiness!

Multiple Choice

A pediatric client substitutes interdentalized sounds for s and z and says /θɪnk/ for sink; phonemic contrasts are intact. What is the most likely diagnosis?

Explanation:
The key idea is distinguishing an articulation issue from a phonological one. Substituting interdental fricatives for s and z is a motor placement problem—a lispy production where the tongue position changes how the sound is formed. Saying /θɪnk/ for sink shows this kind of single-sound substitution, not a broader pattern across many sounds. Because phonemic contrasts are intact, the child knows the difference between sounds and can use them correctly in principle; the trouble is just in producing the sounds with the right place and manner. In a phonological disorder, you’d expect systematic, across-the-board pattern errors that affect many sounds and/or a loss of contrasts. The error here is isolated, consistent, and motor-based, which points to an articulation disorder.

The key idea is distinguishing an articulation issue from a phonological one. Substituting interdental fricatives for s and z is a motor placement problem—a lispy production where the tongue position changes how the sound is formed. Saying /θɪnk/ for sink shows this kind of single-sound substitution, not a broader pattern across many sounds.

Because phonemic contrasts are intact, the child knows the difference between sounds and can use them correctly in principle; the trouble is just in producing the sounds with the right place and manner. In a phonological disorder, you’d expect systematic, across-the-board pattern errors that affect many sounds and/or a loss of contrasts. The error here is isolated, consistent, and motor-based, which points to an articulation disorder.

Subscribe

Get the latest from Passetra

You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy